PonyPOV WorldBuilding113 Soul of Fluttercruel

On the matter of Dark World Fluttercruel's raising and of Dark World Fluttercruel's soul.

Since Fluttercruel was born on the Day of Chaos, that means she was born INSIDE the dark world loop.

That means she has no past outside of it.

Fluttercruel's raising we see in the final loop, is a combination of Discord's initial raising of her into a monster, and Discord's desperate attempts to subvert it.

Nightmare Eclipse likely edited in Discord's actions from multiple earlier loops, taking everything to make Fluttercruel into as much a complete monster as possible. Why? It hurt Discord. And it made her feel more justified in doing what she was doing in a inversion of cause and effect.

In other words, the only reason SO MANY of her were unspeakable monsters is because Eclipse kept editing in 'the best parts' from previous loops.

This would explain why even Rarity couldn't understand how Fluttercruel had gone from a bully to a complete psychotic.

And, SINCE Fluttercruel is born inside the dark world loop, that means her soul is basically a NEW ONE born from Fluttershy and Discord's spiritual essence each time!

And being a deity, Discord is able to appreciate the uniqueness of souls, and so he KNOWS that he's losing one daughter after another . . . he's made a father, only to lose his child each time.